“Longtime fans of Jeffrey Lewis treat each of his albums like a returning old friend. We know what to expect by now – scratchy, lo-fi punk and croaky anti-folk – yet we also know his lyrical wit still has the capacity to surprise.  […] He wrestles with neighbourhood crackheads, the pressures of settling down and – who else could tackle this? – the stress of having to pay your drummer on support tours. Lewis is unlikely to ever dramatically change; instead his music slowly develops and wizens, as we all do. It’ll be fun growing old with him.” **** – Tim Jonze, The Guardian

“Lewis’s catchiest and finest album…  Pushing 40 now, this second-generation bohemian knows his turf from “Scowling Crackhead Ian,” where the kid who held a knife to his throat in junior high is still befouling St. Marks Place, to “The Pigeon,” which stuffs some 30 choice Yiddishisms—“schnorrer,” “verkakte,” “furshlugginer,” oy gevalt—into a Poe-parodying Delancey Street anti-gentrification kvetch. As promised only a hell of a lot slower, he spends nearly five minutes collecting his thoughts in “It Only Takes a Moment.” But he gets where he’s going just about every time.” (Grade: A) – Robert Christgau, Vice

“For me, Jeffrey Lewis has always been an artist on the cusp of something truly brilliant… This album is where Lewis’s songwriting abilities and instincts have nearly caught up with what have always been superior story telling skills. … This is the album where Jeffrey Lewis has finally arrived as songwriter… Jeffrey Lewis has finally written an album that people will look back on in twenty years and say this was the first album in what will hopefully be seen as his classic period.” ****1/2 – Punk News (Staff Pick)

“One of his strongest outings ever” – SPIN (Overlooked Albums Report)

“Singer/songwriter and underground comic book artist Jeffrey Lewis is known for writing sharp, literate, touching, and often hilarious songs about subjects ranging from acid freakouts to historical events, but Manhattan (his seventh full-length for Rough Trade) focuses on tales relating to his home borough… […] As great as Lewis is at penning punchy, acerbic songs like these, he’s still a master at taking his time to craft a calmly paced narrative, as best exemplified here by the jaw-dropping eight-minute centerpiece ‘Back to Manhattan'” – **** – Paul Simpson, AllMusic